ORIGINAL AIR DATE:
August 3, 2026
LENGTH:
1 hour, 27 minutes
A.J. Rohde (00:00:00):
That I think is some of the secret to the success, is now we run the portfolio, the good companies at almost a 50% margin, growing 20%. Back then we would high five at 25 and we would high five at 10% growth. Now it's 20% growth, 50% margin. And so we've just continually gotten a little bit better at helping teams prosecute this idea over time, and that's maintained our competitive edge, people's willingness to work with us, because we back existing management, teach them how to do this is, a wonderful thing. I think it's one of the gifts of my life is being able to help and work with people to be a lot better than they were before.
(00:00:39):
Hi guys. I'm A.J. Rohde, senior partner here at Thoma Bravo. I'm dropping into Thoma Bravo's behind the deal feed to let you know season five is nearly here. But first, we've got a bonus episode for you. I recently joined my friends Rick Buhrman and Paul Buser on the Joys of Compounding podcast. They have discussions with top investors, company builders, academics, athletes, and artists, all exploring compounding in business and in life. You should definitely check it out. On this episode, we go deep on Thoma Bravo's firm history, what makes a strong team, and how the drive to grow and win never really turns off. We also can't help but get into one of my favorite topics and something that most people know sets us apart, which is tennis. Enjoy this bonus episode and we'll have more for you very soon.
Rick Buhrman (00:01:26):
I want to begin with an aspect of Thoma Bravo that I don't think most people really appreciate, and yet I think it's a source of great advantage for the firm. I'm talking about talent, not the investing software kind, although maybe we'll get to that. I'm talking about tennis. From what I hear, you guys are stacked with more tennis talent than probably any other firm, of any kind, in the country. I personally at least have been curious to understand better how that all took shape. I assume it started with Orlando, but if you don't mind just sharing with us a little bit about the history of tennis in the culture of Thoma Bravo.
A.J. Rohde (00:02:21):
Yeah. No, I'd love to. I love talking about tennis and there's a common theme or thread among tennis players as you know, always a little bit screw loose, but pretty resilient. I would say Orlando was the first of the bunch. He grew up in Puerto Rico, spent his years in an academy in Florida, most people know that, and was top 40 in the country in juniors, ended up playing at Brown, had a successful college career at Brown. And everyone who knows him or watches his public persona, he's just wired a certain way. And so when you're wired that way, you tend to want to be around other people who are equally as crazy and wired the same way. And so then that manifested years later when we had an actual business with him hiring my partner Holden, Holden Spaht and Holden played at Dartmouth. Those were the two cornerstones.
(00:03:12):
And then I show up and interview and he finds out I played at Villanova and I was a good junior player. And of course we're talking like two crazy tennis players in the interview and he's like, "Wow, maybe there's a little more of this to go around." So then they hire me. And then as the years go by, I think some of it was circumstantial. We would meet people that had a tennis background and you just click. And then I think after a while, like anything, we started to realize there were patterns in some of this. There were systematic patterns and there were really good investment results that were coming from people that had that background, especially with the play the next ball, play the next ball. You got smacked on that point and you got hit with an overhead like next ball. And there was a very much a resilience to the investment business that comes from that.
(00:03:59):
And so we ended up then being a little bit more methodical about it. And that's when I met Jeff Appel who runs the finance cup, we'll talk about Jeff later, who then started sending me a pipeline of these incredible tennis players, top of their class at UVA, top of their class at Stanford, top 20 in the country in NCAA. And I started interviewing a bunch of them and of course a few of them clicked and now we have a lot of them on our team and a big pipeline of more. But I think that we've actually had a track record now of successful people that are tennis players at our firm. And so we're going to continue to do that. And there's been some evolutions of the sport over time and the players are getting better and better and better and better. And frankly, the top 100 guys in division one college tennis are basically professional athletes.
(00:04:49):
And so what they want to do after college may change a little bit. So we have to evolve there. And it's the same on the women's side. We have a number of female tennis players at our firm too. So it's a common psycho trait of your DNA, I think that seems to work well in our business.
Rick Buhrman (00:05:03):
Well, let's not leave the audience with such a cliffhanger. Let's get into this Finance Cup because I had a chance really just to spend time with Jeff a few weeks ago and it was coming off of this year's Finance Cup, which I know you participated in. A bunch of my friends, one of my former teammates, Javier Taborga, Milos Raonic, who has just retired from tennis, former world number three, amazing dude, brilliant guy. Most people cannot appreciate this, but he's literally in the midst of starting a second career in finance and investing. He's at Goldman Sachs right now. Maybe you can just give us a sense for how you got involved in the format and some of the usual suspects.
A.J. Rohde (00:05:54):
Yeah. And this may exist in other sports too. And if it doesn't, it should. But the Finance Cup started 2015, I believe. Jeff Appel, who is, I call him the godfather of New York tennis. And to some degree, the patriarch of helping to place all these great kids, great superstar players into great jobs. Connecting those people with people that like to hire those people, that's a hard thing to do. And I give him immense credit for being a mentor, being a connector, being a helper for all these kids to end up with great careers after tennis. So 2015 finance club, Bill Ackman, who most people know, very famous investor of Pershing Square, Bill and Jeff hatched the idea to start to connect some of the younger folks in the New York tennis scene to some of the private equity hedge fund investment banking leaders in New York City.
(00:06:49):
It was mostly New York City. And over time, as these things happen, they just organically evolved. He set up a format where there's a European team as well run or kind of created by a guy named Christer Gardell, who's also a hedge fund manager in London. And so they would start to connect and say, "Well, why don't we have our guys play against your guys?" And so they started doing this and what it originally was, was the really young players playing with some of the older players that were more established in business. That evolved and continued to evolve and you added new players every time, both in the European team and the American team. And then it became really a much bigger deal. Three day event every year alternates continents. Over time, my guess is it continues to just keep expanding. Logistically, it's challenging to pull all this together.
(00:07:41):
Spouses come. I mean, it's a big three day event deal. There's dinners, a bunch of social activities, but I've been at it for several years now. And honestly, guys, it's been one of the joys of my personal and professional life. And the funny story is we were in Newport, Rhode Island last summer. So summer 2025, that was where it was. And my wife comes, this is the first time Melissa got to come because we live in San Francisco and oftentimes it's in Europe and somewhere far away. And so she came and she watches me interact for two days with basically 70 other guys who are just like me, just totally nuts. And I met my wife right after college, right when I stopped playing. And we've been together, married 20 years, together 23. So she doesn't really know me as that tennis guy, although I have the wiring.
(00:08:33):
And she watches it for two days and we're at dinner at Marble House that night with a big black tie dinner and she's like, "Okay, I finally get you now, man." So it took that for her to observe what it's like because everyone's kind of cut from the same intensity cloth.
Rick Buhrman (00:08:50):
That's amazing. This kind of community that's being fashioned and the reciprocity, the way in which of course everybody's having fun doing the things that you mutually love, but where there is kind of purpose beyond that, and you hear that when you talk to Jeff, you hear that everybody's out there sort of thinking about on the margin, how do they contribute and pay it forward to these younger players. It's a really cool tradition. I hope it continues.
Paul Buser (00:09:21):
Well, what's funny is it's like a total outsider to this. I probably should say something before you guys go for 20 more minutes on tennis. Rick had the same thing. He stopped playing tennis for a very long time for various reasons. He had kids and work. And then we moved to Florida here on the west coast of Florida when we built our holding company, Cedar Grove.
Rick Buhrman (00:09:44):
I literally lived-handed
Paul Buser (00:09:45):
Backhand and did all these different -
Rick Buhrman (00:09:46):
I live a half a mile from the original courts, the original military courts where Orlando likely was training. It's like -
A.J. Rohde (00:09:55):
Full circle.
Rick Buhrman (00:09:55):
This whole area is filled with the ghosts of tennis past. But sorry, Paul, you were about to say something eloquent.
Paul Buser (00:10:04):
Yeah, it'd be good to get Rick plugged in there if he'd add some value.
A.J. Rohde (00:10:13):
I think Rick's contribution professionally is finance, so why don't we just put him on the roster? He's pretty damn good.
Paul Buser (00:10:18):
I want to hear if you guys ever played each other back in the old Big East.
A.J. Rohde (00:10:21):
No, I played one of his old teammates once in juniors. We would always go deep in the conference run, but we would usually lose to Miami. And then Miami would play Notre Dame in the finals of the Big East every single year. So Rick used to play in Miami.
Rick Buhrman (00:10:36):
Miami has always been a huge rival for Notre Dame across football and other sports. They were a big rival of ours in tennis. And I know we have mutual friends who played for that team.
A.J. Rohde (00:10:50):
Rudy, Michael Russell.
Rick Buhrman (00:10:51):
Michael Russell, of course, who's coaching Taylor Fritz right now.
A.J. Rohde (00:10:56):
Beast. Yeah. Also a Michigan guy, Michael Russell.
Rick Buhrman (00:11:00):
Yeah. I knew there was something about him that -
A.J. Rohde (00:11:02):
Grew up right near me. I know. Short, underappreciated Michigan guy.
Rick Buhrman (00:11:06):
Well, let's talk a little bit about Michigan. I mean, and maybe as a segue, just how you got into tennis. You grew up in Grosse Pointe. Tell us just that story and then we'll open it up to more from the early days.
A.J. Rohde (00:11:20):
Yeah. I'm a midwesterner, fifth generation Detroiter, on both sides of my family. Same town that the family had lived in for a hundred years. My mom's brother was a college tennis player who left to move to Texas right after he graduated. And actually right when John Newcomb was opening the very famous Australian tennis player, John Newcomb, multiple time grand slam winner, had lived in Texas after he retired and started a tennis academy, a ranch called the Newcomb Ranch, which is still very active today.
Rick Buhrman (00:11:55):
Still
A.J. Rohde (00:11:55):
Going,
Rick Buhrman (00:11:56):
Yeah. Yeah.
A.J. Rohde (00:11:56):
And I spent a ton of time there as a youth. My kids now go there every summer. It's like the highlight of their summer. They go grind in the San Antonio heat for two weeks in June. But my uncle Phil left Michigan, went to Newcomb and became the director of the Newcomb Ranch in the 80s at a pretty young age, like in his 20s, and when it was just getting started. As a multiple sport athlete, I played every sport you can imagine as a kid. I played junior hockey, I played junior soccer, I played soccer in high school, played basketball in high school. So I was just constantly moving. One of those, it's like a shark. If you stop moving, you die. I still do have this kind of fidgety rhythm. So I played a bunch of things, but I always had this connection to Phil because of his prodigious tennis background.
(00:12:45):
And so I started going there and playing and I really fell in love with it. And I think I'm one of the, I'm probably a lot like you, Rick. I like to do things solo sometimes, like to be hard on myself. Tennis was a good... Tennis is not for everybody, but it was good for my personality type. And so I started playing a lot, getting good at that. I would go down to the ranch, I'd come back. We had a really good cluster of guys in my town or in related towns during that era. I always find these ecosystems feed on each other. Look at that Taylor Fritz, Riley Opelka, Tommy Paul, Frances Tiafoe, look at that cohort. They're all excelling because they came up and competed with each other simultaneously. There's kind of other examples that like the private equity business too.
Rick Buhrman (00:13:30):
Sure.
A.J. Rohde (00:13:31):
And so that fed on itself. So I think we all made each other better.
Rick Buhrman (00:13:35):
So sports was big in your life from an early age. Rumor is you're also quite a musician and yeah, we're looking at Rush behind you. Maybe say a little bit about that and maybe let's frame it. If you had to build a soundtrack to your life, what are some of the songs, bands that would populate it?
A.J. Rohde (00:13:58):
As a drummer, most of what I listen to is very percussive. It's very intense. It's very rhythmic. I would say my daily soundtrack for when things are moving, Limelight by Rush, The National has a song called Apartment Story, which I love, which reminds me of what it's like to live in a crappy old apartment in your 20s and just kind of get through life and grind through it, but just enjoy those moments and know that that's a formative time in your life.
Rick Buhrman (00:14:32):
Anytime you want to kind of go back to Midwest dark winters, I feel like National is a good way to go.
A.J. Rohde (00:14:39):
100%. Gloomy as it can be. Very good drummer too. And then another song is Unsatisfied by the Replacements because I think it does sum up a little bit what it feels like to be an investor sometimes. You're always a little bit unsatisfied. You're very happy with I put the work in, I went to sleep that night, I did what I could do, but you're always a little bit unsatisfied that there's work left to be done. And I think that song resonates a little bit with me. So for me, they're all those intense driving rock songs with
Rick Buhrman (00:15:10):
A
A.J. Rohde (00:15:10):
Lot of melodies
Rick Buhrman (00:15:12):
And
A.J. Rohde (00:15:12):
Soaring guitars. That would be
Rick Buhrman (00:15:14):
The
A.J. Rohde (00:15:14):
Soundtrack to my limbic system or nervous system.
Rick Buhrman (00:15:17):
I think one of the things that's interesting to me right out of the gates is when you decide to embrace music like that, it usually consumes you and you're not out there playing five, six sports and vice versa. If you're playing sports more the direction that I went, I look back, if I had to list regrets of my youth that still I might dream about every once in a while, it would be that I didn't maintain pursuing being a musician or just not necessarily to make it as a musician, but more just for the joy that music gives me and how important it feels, how central it feels like to sort of the human experience. But it's fascinating that generally these are things that are kind of all consuming. Tennis specifically as a sport, I think is one of those sports that people just generally are laser focused on.
(00:16:15):
But say more about just sort of how you embraced that kind of range early on and still managed to excel in a way where playing number one for Villanova in college is pretty impressive.
A.J. Rohde (00:16:32):
They're all kind of related and they all kind of drive each other. I was just looking for ways to fill my ADHD and drumming, especially the way I drum. I drum like Keith Moon. I'm not as good as Keith Moon, but there's a lot of spastic limb movements and there's a very intense element to it, just like the same way I play tennis. Everything I do is just like another level of intensity. Drumming was a great outlet for me to do that because it was just another way to discharge some of that energy. And I give a lot of credit. The public school system at Michigan back then was very pushy for getting kids to play instruments. And like many public school systems, it would encourage a lot of kids to be in the orchestra, the band. What I think that the world's evolved to a lot, and it's especially true in California and really true where we live in Marin County, is there is a hard push for rock band.
(00:17:23):
And I watch now the kids of my friends who are now in college, and you know what's cool again? Rock band at the fraternity party or at the whatever party is straight up back. Every good party now has a band. They're plugged in. It's a traditional four piece or five piece. They're playing Oasis, they're playing Pearl Jam. They call that dad rock, that stuff that we all grew up on. It's straight up back. I think the fact that rock band again is pervasive, that means everybody's got a role in a band if they want it to be. I think that is such a gift for anybody. Access is a part of your brain you just don't get to access.
Rick Buhrman (00:18:01):
How did music show up in your life? Was that through a family influence as well?
A.J. Rohde (00:18:07):
Again, public school system pushing you into it, me being like, "What instrument should I play? Okay, I need to play drums because I need to get this energy out somehow." And then coming of age, at age 12, 13, 14, during the post Nirvana years or the Nirvana years, I just could never... It'd be like becoming of age in 1966, the same kind of thing. And so we were all so lucky that music was... It defined you as a person in middle school and high school, as you guys know. Were you a Deadhead? Were you a Phish head? Were you a wise propanic person? Were you a classic rock person? Were you an emo person? And I don't think that defines kids anymore, good and bad, but I think that was so important that music was just in your face. So then I started a band with some friends.
(00:18:51):
We had series of high school bands that we played. We played a bunch of shows. We recorded at my house. It was creative in a way that everything else I was doing at the time was much more structured and it was a cool bonding moment amongst the guys in my band and they were different kind of guys because I was used to playing sports and other things. All of a sudden I got exposed to a little bit more alternative emo, even some skateboard types. We were playing some punk rock music. So it's the stuff that being from Michigan playing tennis, you're not going to get exposed to. So another great thing I can talk about now later in life, and it makes me more relatable to people that aren't just in finance or aren't just in this. I think that's a wonderful thing to have when you're trying to bond with people to do deals or just to be empathetic to different kinds of people in the way they think.
Rick Buhrman (00:19:42):
And you still jam, right?
A.J. Rohde (00:19:44):
Still jam. So similar to tennis, though I get out of college, I just absolutely grind at work for a long time. Get a little bit older. My wife has a 40th birthday party, this is some time ago, and we had a jam session at the end of the party and there were a bunch of guitars on the walls. People brought guitars and we were doing a singalong and there's no drums there. So I get out of pillow and I'm drumming and my buddies are like, "Yeah, you know how to play?" I'm like, "Yeah, I've been in bands my whole life." And that hatched the idea to get a dad band together. So we crash coursed the dad band in, we played at our club, that turned into playing with... I'm lucky where I live, there are professional musicians everywhere. It's like a much smaller version in Nashville or Austin.
(00:20:34):
And so we started playing, incorporating some of those guys who were also our buddies into the band. So now we have two bands, concentric circles of friends playing, but man, another finance cup, drumming again, tennis, the joys of things that formed me as a kid to be able to come back full circle and do those things. Not everyone's so lucky. Not everyone gets to live out those things they did in high school because those activities don't exist for them in their 40s, but I'm lucky where they do.
Paul Buser (00:21:02):
So cool to hear. One little aside, our rising senior in high school, our oldest daughter has gotten... And I think she was babysitting Rick's kids as we speak now. While she's not doing that, she's been doing a ton of DJing and this has become a new thing. I know it's electronic still, but I think that these kids are all wanting a freeform way to take these songs and make it their own.
A.J. Rohde (00:21:26):
Incredible.
Paul Buser (00:21:27):
Versus passively listening. So I had no clue she was into this, but it's become a big thing.
A.J. Rohde (00:21:33):
And the software is so good now.
Paul Buser (00:21:35):
So good.
A.J. Rohde (00:21:35):
So intuitive. Yeah.
Rick Buhrman (00:21:36):
There it is. There's the plug for software.
Paul Buser (00:21:39):
Here we go. Here's the turn we needed. Speaking of software, I used a little thing called AI to research a little bit about a time that was kind of prolific at Villanova. That time did not overlap with your time there. A.J.? No. I know you like cohorts of great people. Jay Wright overlapped with one year with you. Senior year. Tell us about those Villanova years. Maybe you can even take us to the Chicago booth too, but just education wise, outside of music, tennis, what happened to Villanova that brought you into this world?
Rick Buhrman (00:22:15):
Let's pretend that things outside of tennis and music actually matter. Talk about those
A.J. Rohde (00:22:20):
Things. Yeah. I don't have much to talk about then. Nova was great because it got me to the East Coast, which I feel like for any kid, not every kid has the same ambition, but for me, I've traveled the world so much. This was the beginning for me to move out of the Midwest and do that. Villanova at the time was mostly kids from the tri-state area, from New York, Connecticut, New Jersey, totally different Pennsylvania, totally different kind of kids than Michigan kids. And that was good too, different personality types. They talked faster. There was a little more braggadocio, things that I was like, "Oh wow, people talk that way. Okay. Wow." And so I liked the spirit of Philadelphia. So that to me was really important.
(00:23:11):
It's just like Notre Dame. There's a theological component to it. So we were required to take several theology courses. I thought that was great. I'm not an overly religious person. I wasn't back then, I'm not today, but I just think it's nice to have a little bit of that in your life. I don't get much of that in California, our kids don't, but just having a little bit of that was nice. It was a good size school. It wasn't too big. It wasn't too small, 1800 kids per class. So for me, it was just a logical next level of intensity, scale, blue collar city, lots to do around Philly, but not much to do, that kind of thing. I loved it. I wouldn't have traded it for anything. I was lucky. My teammates were amazing. My coach was amazing. Most people, Rick, as you know, back then didn't have great college tennis coaching or cultures.
(00:24:07):
I was super lucky that we did.
Rick Buhrman (00:24:09):
What about academically? I mean, we didn't really talk about that, but what were you interested in? And maybe the answer is not much at the time, but kind of bridge the gap of your education into a career in business and investing.
A.J. Rohde (00:24:28):
I, from a young age, was always fascinated by stories, storytelling, and the stories of the swashbuckling deal guys in the 1980s. All these stories of RJR Nabisco and the corporate Raiders and even Delaware law and how these things happened. I always found that very fascinating, the personalities behind the deals. And my mom was a behavioral psychologist, so I always got a lot of doses of that at home, and I was very keenly aware of different people's motivations. So for me, combining all this energy I had with that psychological piece, with these interesting personality types of the 80s and the storytelling, it sort of wove into a cocktail of deals. Back then I was thinking about as an investment banking. That was the track I was on. So then I was like, "Okay, how do I do that? Undergraduate business, do finance, eventually get a job in investment banking and then just figure it out, work your way up." That was basically my path.
(00:25:38):
It sounds sort of lame, but I used to watch the movie Wall Street all the time when I was a kid. Michael Douglas was not a hero, but it was just interesting that people would talk that way and think that way, and there was this whole ecosystem of people. And being a super competitive guy, I always remember being like, "I have a lot of energy. I have reasonably good way of putting it all together. I could do that, but be a better person."
Paul Buser (00:26:00):
On this point, we've heard you say before that if you were an investor, you'd like to be a coach. We've also heard about you from others that you're an amazing mentor internally there and you like to build teams. That doesn't always fit with being Gordon Gekko or kind of the lone ranger or even a tennis player. Sometimes it's great as a team player, but oftentimes you're also kind of on your own thinking about yourself. Where did that come from and how did that start to show up in this early investment career?
A.J. Rohde (00:26:29):
I think I have enough self-awareness and I give Orlando and Carl a lot of credit. This is very much a team sport still. And as much as the world likes to honor the single investor type, I think the best investors are very quick to acknowledge there is a whole interdependent infrastructure that makes them successful. And I am unbelievably willing and excited to admit that because there are so many things that can't happen unless you have great people believing in the mission around you that also share your level of energy and frankly can round out your deficiencies or your edges. We have a great partnership now. We have seven of us that run the investment committee. And I would say if you looked at it, everybody complements someone else's blind spot. And that was not by design, of course, it just happens. And then good people find each other, they compliment each other out and they stay together for a long time, especially if you can check egos at the door.
(00:27:34):
This industry tends to be very humbling. Some people get overly arrogant and they eventually get wiped out or you're humble. Sometimes you're too humble and you don't take enough risk. So I think we have a good balance of that, but I've just watched my partners be so reliant upon each other. Orlando gets a lot of public accolades for what he's built and he should, but Orlando's also very quick to admit that without the partners, this does not work. I always heard that from the guys. I would see it. I would observe it. I always felt that way about myself. So as we were building teams, I just wanted to emulate that. And so today you'll hear me a lot say, for example, the podcast that we do, I make sure that the principals or junior partners are on every single one with me because I just think it's important that you give young people a lot of agency to make those decisions as long as you're there with them in the trenches and you support them to take a little bit of risk.
Paul Buser (00:28:33):
How do you think the origin story feeds into that? It's been told before, but maybe you can give the abbreviated version of how this whole thing came together and then why, I think it was around 2010, you joined as the first analyst or one of the first team members.
A.J. Rohde (00:28:50):
VPs, yeah.
Paul Buser (00:28:51):
Yeah, VPs and what the vision was at that point. I don't know. Yeah, just take us to that grounding of how this culture came about and then why you joined.
Rick Buhrman (00:29:03):
And if you don't mind, I mean, I think one of the things that is less appreciated is the chapters prior to Thoma Bravo being Thoma Bravo and the ways in which that kind of still sort of manifests in how things are done there.
A.J. Rohde (00:29:19):
Yeah. Venture capital and private equity was not even a cottage industry. It was a nothing industry in the 70s, right? And inside of First Chicago Bank were a couple rogue bankers who wanted to start doing venture investing. One of them was a guy named Stan Golder and Stan Golder's mentee was Carl Thoma. So Carl was just a young employee at the bank, Stanford MBA, grew up in the panhandle of Oklahoma, classic Ben Graham, Warren Buffett disciple, don't lose money, number one. Number two, don't lose money. It's like that kind of mindset, which is tough in the venture business. So Carl and Stan spun out, created their own firm in 1980 called Golder Thoma. That firm in 1982 was credited at the time for being the originator of the buy and build strategy in private equity. We all call those roll ups today, but the idea at the time was there was a lot of value to be made by consolidating industries.
(00:30:24):
So it was Stan's experience, it was Carl's energy and kind of that don't lose money investment heuristic. And those two started rolling up all these disparate markets at the time.
Paul Buser (00:30:36):
How did that differ, just as an aside here, because you mentioned RJR, famous book, Barbarians at the Gate. And then we do a lot of things with Mitch Rales and he's been an incredible mentor and influence on what we're building. And when you get the guy telling those stories of the early 80s, their first company, they borrowed five million, it was a six million purchase price, and then they borrowed another million to pay the rest. Essentially the whole thing was on debt. So you hear those stories, but there's not as much history on this buy and build. What was the cap structure like or how did it differ from some of the folks really pushing the boundaries and LBOs?
A.J. Rohde (00:31:13):
They would raise a structured fund. It was a dedicated fund. They would find an industry theme that they liked, some fragmented market. That was really the sourcing strategy. Then they would find an executive that they felt comfortable prosecuting that strategy. And I'll contrast that to where we've evolved today, which is the opposite. We back existing management and teach them how to be better operators. But they found an industry executive and a massively fragmented market. They would give them just enough capital to go buy enough assets to aggregate up and bootstrap it from there. And then they would push them hard on financial excellence, operational excellence, but it wasn't that rigorous in that regard at the time. They were just really good about picking fragmented markets, picking the right person, and then just go, go, go, go. And because Carl had come from a value investing DNA, even though it was venture business, everything was rooted in good unit economics.
(00:32:11):
And so there was always that discipline or adherence like this is the right roll up because once we get to scale, we know there's negative churn, there are great gross margins, there's capital efficiency, all those things. And so those became the best deals, the best one of all of them when the spectrum was deregulated in 1984, Carl and his wife and partners, they would go to courthouses all around the country and they would apply for licenses for pieces of air. And that formulated the basis of a company called PageNet. But that was the ultimate example of regulation changing an industry. Nobody was doing it, going and building it yourself literally by hand, finding someone to run it and then being super aggressive about it. But you could buy most, continue to aggregate spectrum financed by the banks at that time so they could do that with very little equity.
(00:33:08):
And then they sold it at the perfect time before cellular became more pervasive and cell phones became more pervasive. And that launched a strategy or that was the cornerstone of a strategy that then was applied to lots of different industries, some good, some bad, golf courses, newspapers, funeral homes. And that was our firm for 20 years. And then that's when Orlando joined in the late '90s. And we could talk about that next, but that's when really the basis for what became Thoma Bravo was then started.
Paul Buser (00:33:46):
Maybe just keep going a little further. Why an inflection point or what led to the split or Thoma Bravo being its own thing?
A.J. Rohde (00:33:56):
So Golder Thoma added a third partner eventually called Cressey and then a fourth called Rauner and that's GTCR. So that's GTCR today. Most people know GTCR, great firm. We have a lot of friends over there. We have this common DNA. Eventually the T and the C, Toma and Cressey spun out, created their own firm. I think it was probably just a little bit of difference of opinion on investment strategy at the time and nothing substantially more salacious than that. I think it was more like that. And Toma and Cressey started their own middle market firm prosecuting the same strategy out of Chicago. We had an office in San Francisco. It was more of an outpost. There was a partner here. That partner hired Scott Crabill, who's my partner now in Orlando.
(00:34:48):
All the capital that was invested at that time in tech was all IT services. It was all Y2K readiness companies, which sounds hilarious. Those investments, many of them went to zero. So the beginning of Orlando's investment career came from very humble beginnings and he's so talented, but it was the wrong time. It was the wrong businesses. I don't think they had learned enough yet about IT services to do that. And many firms, that dot com bubble took down many great private equity firms, you guys know. So Orlando's sitting there, late 20s, like, "Man, my investment career is not very good, not what I thought it would be. What do I do next?" And he discovered through just a little bit of industry work, he got introduced to an executive named Marcel Bernard who ended up becoming sort of the godfather of some of our operational metrics and playbook.
(00:35:45):
Those two linked up through introductions. Marcel had come from Motorola and he ran a number of software companies in Canada. So he had taken these lean manufacturing Six Sigma operating principles and started to apply them to building and shipping and distributing software. It's an incredibly revolutionary idea. And Orlando saw it and Marcel was one of these guys, he just loved to stay in that zone, tinker there. All he wanted was to advise management and be helpful. He's just one of those wonderful human beings you've ever met who just obsessed about their craft and just wants to do their craft. So Orlando's like, okay, this guy that can help and maybe we can apply this to application software, which at the time, by the way, was trading at one and a half times revenue, two and a half times maintenance. I mean, it was amazing the values you look back in hindsight for vertical market application companies.
(00:36:41):
They were all selling licenses and maintenance. Back then there was no ASP, there was no SaaS and there were no financing market for it. So the banks were not in the intellectual property lending business. They were in the hard asset business. So Orlando finds a company, Yardley PA, small public company called Prophet 21. Chuck Boyle's the CEO. He's still a friend of ours today. They take it private. And the thing Marcel taught was in a headcount business, you could take out 10% of the headcount costs of a company upfront without disrupting the operations one bit and you could go up to 20 upfront if you're thoughtful about it. And we'll get into why and how and all that. And so what ended up happening is Chuck, there were a lot of skunkworks projects, a lot of science projects at the company. So we shelved those.
(00:37:31):
Then we started using that extra capacity to borrow from a banks a little bit and fund, I think we made six acquisitions in P21. And the bell goes off at that point. It's like, wow, obviously they're great business models, but there is a process we could run where if we back existing management, focus on product P&Ls. So what are we building and what's the return on that? Focus on breaking the company into a manufacturing center, which is R&D and a sales center, which is your distributor and thinking about the metrics that way. We could bootstrap the companies. They can self-sustain and self-grow. They can grow faster. They could finance growth through M&A, and that's a good model. And that's when we started to do it one at a time. And then it was Vector SGI and then it was Attachmate. We were together, Cressey, Toma, and Bravo was not on the door.
(00:38:26):
The name wasn't on the door yet. And we had the idea. Cressey was doing a lot of healthcare, which they still do today very well, pharmaceutical development, a different business than enterprise software. So we agreed to split. So Thoma Bravo was created as the software team inside Thoma Cressey. That was 2008. We call that fund nine because we traced the lineage back to day one, but that's really our first dedicated fund for that. I joined about a year and a half after that and I just helped continue. At that point, I give Orlando another enormous amount of credit. We just kept getting a little better at our craft every year. And that I think is some of the secret to the success is now we run the portfolio, the good companies at almost a 50% margin, growing 20%. Back then we would high five at 25 and we would high five at 10% growth.
(00:39:23):
Now it's 20% growth, 50% margin. And so we've just continually gotten a little bit better at helping teams prosecute this idea over time. And that's maintained our competitive edge, people's willingness to work with us because we back existing management, teach them how to do this. It's a wonderful thing. I think it's one of the gifts of my life is being able to help and work with people to be a lot better than they were before, at least operationally. So that's kind of how the firm then took another leap forward and then we could talk about what that looked like, but that's kind of the history.
Rick Buhrman (00:39:54):
One of the things that Paul and I have done in our more distant past was begin to try to study firms that were able to perpetuate success, call it at least a few decades. And there's not that many. I mean, to think that some iteration of this firm is coming up on 50 years, one of the things that just strikes me is the willingness to adapt, to evolve, to learn new things or to pay attention when something is working.
Paul Buser (00:40:30):
By the way, there's also spinoffs, almost like a company and you kind of let the steam out or let new skunk works that are becoming reality take off just
Rick Buhrman (00:40:42):
Massive adaptation. I'm curious, what else would you say is sort of the constants? What else is the first principles that don't change that help to kind of enable this continued growth and cultivation of an edge? Because it is highly, highly abnormal. I think the simple version would be that this firm was sort of built with a heavy dose of luck, stumbled into software, software has been this incredible place for a few decades and end of story. But that couldn't be further from the truth when you really unpack it. And even if it's just kind of taking the 15, 16 years that you've been there, what are the things that you all kind of hold most dear in terms of guiding values, principles, et cetera?
A.J. Rohde (00:41:46):
One of the reasons the partnerships fracture is because people get a little bit tired of the job sometimes and what the job requires. I think the extracurriculars start to creep in for a lot of private equity partners. Yo guys know this. Egos start to creep in.
Rick Buhrman (00:42:00):
Guys start playing tennis too much.
A.J. Rohde (00:42:02):
Exactly, exactly. Yeah. You have to treat that as additive, not dilutive. If you watch this, we are very much the same wolf pack that we were before and all we care about when we're together is investing, investing, investing, investing, deals, deals, deals getting a little better. It is a rabid curiosity about the job and that I'm very, very, I'm just so proud I got to stumble into an operation that everybody's north star is that to this day. And so that's number one. Number two, failure is totally fine here. We have to be really smart about risk management and picking the right stocks and all that, but this is not a place where there is a shroud over your head or cloud over your head to fail or take risk or do those things. A very, very supportive culture in that regard.
(00:42:57):
Lastly, I think because we all grew up pretty humbly and all I think were raised pretty well by good parents who taught us a lot about other people and emotional intelligence and all that. We are lucky that we all have a pretty good compass on backing really nice, earnest, and the best quote I ever heard is an honest man's pillow is his peace of mind from John Mellencamp. That's how we live our firm. That's how the people we back are. That's why we have so many Midwestern companies. So I'm very grateful that we have this thing where we just find really, really well intentioned, capable, creative people that we can give our capital to and then they're open-minded to our expertise. So I think we pick stocks well like most good investors, but I actually think we pick the people in charge of those enterprises really well.
(00:43:57):
And that's because we run our firm with the same kind of principles.
Paul Buser (00:44:01):
I'm so fascinated by this idea of all the iterations that have happened amidst these constancies and thinking about you guys getting better over time and yet the opportunity set, it's kind of like you just wait for the same fat pitch over and over again where it's this Midwestern mentality owner. And so two questions come out of that. One is, why does that persist? Why is this opportunity there that you guys have built your operational and financial playbook and it's extremely useful still to all these people? And the private equity industry has grown massively. You think somehow that would get competed away. And then the second part is because you're so good at this, there's some great stories about you guys winning the deal just because of who you are. The private equity model means you need to build this, optimize and sell. Have you guys thought about holding longer?
(00:44:56):
Again, going back to this mentality of if you're creating with current management this sort of bond, what is it that creates the need or desire for everyone around the table to kind of optimize and then bring it to a new home? Whether that's, I don't know, new IPO or strategic or somehow selling to another private equity?
A.J. Rohde (00:45:14):
Yeah. So the first question, I think we appeal to the ambitious business builder type who wants to take their game up like three levels, not one level and do it now and are open-minded to doing that. And then once you get there, climb another big hill, which is probably make a material acquisition. So we win a lot or we endure a lot because that's how we built our firm. And so we tend to appeal to those people really well. Now that's not for everybody. And I also think that the industry has become, good and bad, very institutional.
(00:46:06):
So there are investment committees that span across big asset managers and they're looking for risk management and they have a big LP that has a separately managed account that has put this much in credit and this much in buyout, this much in secondaries. A lot of firms manage to these return objectives and don't rock the boat objectives. I would say our group is still very artisanal in how we do deals and how we make decisions and how we support an entrepreneur to do something big once we own the company. There is not any formal hierarchical decision making, approval, acceptance. There's a lot of data and a lot of gut instinct on people and their ability to execute. And so people generally like to work with us who have that same way of running their own company. And so the industry hasn't copied that I think because most firms aren't, the DNA is not that or they've become organizationally confined to something else that makes that kind of like, no, we got this.
(00:47:13):
No, we're in a board meeting now. We're going to approve a $500 million investment. We've been talking about it for two months. We're going to do it today. I don't need to go back to all of our partners and talk about this for four more months. That kind of mindset, people generally really like it and I think it allows us just to move a lot faster. And so we try to appeal to people that would really value that.
Paul Buser (00:47:37):
What about on the second piece of then when that goes really well, because we think about this, the compounding equation a lot, it's like a lot of, can you hold the right tail just a little longer? And maybe it'd be interesting to see how you design that across funds, but where that's gone well or maybe a buy and build just feels like it has another five years in it after the typical end because you see a lot of targets or the management is that good.
A.J. Rohde (00:48:03):
Tiger by the tail. Yeah. I would say we've evolved this over time. Historically we used to hold for like three and a half years. That wasn't by design. It was like we would buy, we'd push hard, management would do a great job, we'd do these great acquisitions and then someone would come calling and want to buy it. So we sold in three years. Now we do the same thing, same urgency. We've had to pay a little more over time than we used to pay. So some of that arbitrage, quick arbitrage gets kind of arbed away. But now because the companies are bigger, liquidity in the private markets is less, people are being more selective on the assets they buy, all those things. That notion that we do all that and someone just comes and say, "I want to buy it now," that used to be 80% of the time.
(00:48:53):
Now it might be 30% of the time. So what are we then required to do as a market reality? Hold longer, build more value, be more thoughtful about year 10 in the investment horizon, whether we own in year 10, someone who's going to buy from us is going to care about year 10 because they're going to buy from us in year seven. We've evolved over the last eight years to think more about year 10, year 15 with the same urgency that we would run for year three in the old way. And that does require a little bit more screening of the leadership, the CEO and his or her team that they appreciate that they have a tiger by the tail and they want to keep doing it all together for 10 years. Just like if you gave Thoma Bravo money at this age, you know we're all together in 10 more years because what the hell else are we going to do?
(00:49:48):
This is all we love to do. It's all we ever do. So you have to find those people now and that is becoming more of a rare commodity because the tech industry, people change jobs. And so I would say the filter of investment ideas for us is super wide. The funnel narrowing for finding people that want to do that have delivered through COVID, through the introduction of GPT-3, all these complicated industry things we've been through over the last six years, that's a smaller group and we don't have to buy that many companies. We have to buy three a year in each fund, that's it. But we have to be more and more and more judicious about finding those people and supporting those people over time.
Paul Buser (00:50:34):
Yeah. It's such an interesting nuance on that fire. Like you're finding these unique leaders that in the past, three or four years, they can run really hard. You all know that you're aiming at something that's a much different ballgame when you're looking at seven to 10 years in terms of the energy level and the ambition. What other just metrics that you look for have evolved, say from 2010 - ish to now? And it could be around gross retention or end markets or the ability to change margins or organic growth rates. Anything else come to mind?
A.J. Rohde (00:51:08):
NPS, the support of the customers for the product. I think years ago when the customer made a capital investment to buy perpetual license and built a bunch of infrastructure around that, they were stuck.
Rick Buhrman (00:51:22):
Captive, yeah.
A.J. Rohde (00:51:23):
They were captive. It's like Oracle or SAP, you can never get off. That was true in vertical market software for years as well. I think when the world went to SaaS, the switching costs went down. Now that the world is agents plus deterministic SaaS systems, that could be another step function for people to consider, of course it is, to consider what their architectures look like. And frankly, evaluating their own business processes. One, we call 100 customers and actually talk to the business buyer, what they care about. That customer connectivity is of paramount importance. That always used to be important. Now it's like number one, two, and three. And that's a combination of revenue and EBITDA growth. It's that simple. And it usually manifests itself in one number every year. That number becomes written in Sanskrit on the walls of the company and every strategic decision, business plan, building cushions to that buffer goes against that.
(00:52:25):
And so people, when they're doing these transformational operational approaches, it's really nice to give a simple target. And so the management team's excitement about those targets, like, no, no, I can hit those, I can beat those and here's how, that's an enormous screening tool for us as well. So it's got to have the same tenets of the investment thesis that every other PE firm's going to have. We have a bunch of weird nuanced ones around retention that we could get in today if you want that are really germane to SaaS and AI. But I would say in general, it's this customer feedback meets the team's excitement about a plan that we put in front of them that usually involves some level of transformation around more growth and way more margin.
Rick Buhrman (00:53:15):
You set up these incentives, not predicated on the outcome, but it just kind of reminds me of the mungerism. Show me the incentives and I'll show you the outcome. It's like if you achieve a four year plan with operational excellence, it puts you in a great position to be able to do a lot of things. And if you don't, then those options aren't there, but it gets to the essence of the thing you're actually trying to do, which is to perpetuate what you already believe to be a great business. And like you said, take it a couple notches up.
Paul Buser (00:53:52):
On one of our most recent podcasts, we had Nilam Gananthiran who runs Beacon Software now, which is buying a bunch of small software companies all over North America. He used to run Instacart and his former chief lieutenant who's now CEO of Instacart, we spoke with him just in preparation, thinking about AI. And Nilam has a highly technical team that's trying to go in these small businesses and bring AI to them. And we'll get to AI in a minute. I know Rick has some questions, but when I asked him about what the threat is for say an Instacart, who has an installed base of customers, and obviously there's the end consumers, but really it's these retailers that they have to worry about. And he said risk is only measured in terms of whether your clients are happy. And with AI, now they actually can have all the features they want.
(00:54:42):
You can build it for them. So if you get it right, they should be happier and stickier clients than ever. And it just reminds me that it's like in this world, there's a lot of threats, but if you get this right, it can be a tailwind if you use this to your advantage, but you can't rest on your laurels.
A.J. Rohde (00:54:58):
Software companies for years, I think took advantage of the fact that the business model was so good, therefore lost connectivity with their customers, how their customers were using it in operations, how their customers were evolving their own organizational structures, what was happening around their application with both in terms of the org design, but also the other pieces of tech that were touching it. There was a lost connectivity. If you go back to Amazon, that obsessive customer relationship is so much more, it was always important. It's so much more important now that everybody is getting inundated for the idea, do I rebuild these applications using an SLM or an LLM and some consulting company? Do I stick with the incumbent vendor and weave agents and an agentic resource discovery layer in the middle into those applications? Everyone's evaluating their own org design and their own architecture.
(00:55:46):
And if you're not talking to that customer multiple times a week and not selling to them and pushing them and trying to raise price, but you're actually obsessed about how you can help solve their problems, this is why we're so sanguine about the future is because the incumbents have this beautiful opportunity to leverage decreasingly low cost token. I mean, think about the price war that's happening now with inference and with open source models and what that's going to do to the models. So we can leverage that cost of goods sold much better. We can start to point the right query at the right model, kind of like what Baseten does in some of these companies. And then we can maintain Five9's execution and a system that touches every employee at a company, whether they know it or not. Though companies have earned the right to do that, but that's not a birthright.
(00:56:43):
And so if you lose sight of what your customers need and what they're doing, you will lose that absolutely. And if you maintain it, it'll be wonderful. And it's much more binary than it used to be. It used to be a bit of a sliding scale there. Now I think it's existential in how you treat the customers.
Rick Buhrman (00:57:00):
What would you say about the art of executing a great bolt-on strategy or even just acquisitions at large? How do you think about prosecuting that aspect of an investment that you make alongside the team?
A.J. Rohde (00:57:19):
If the companies know how to be smart about integration, that's really important. And when I say that, that the smartness is not the fact that there's a singular process every time, which used to be the prevailing view. You'd buy, you'd integrate, you'd move the customers over in tiers. Forget it. Forget it. Now it's having the emotional awareness to know, okay, I'm going to make this acquisition. I have to keep these eight people. I have to keep this data schema in place. I can move the other data schema over here. We're going to keep the application layer going forever, but it's going to talk to this. I'm going to skin the UI the same way. We're going to have a AI layer above it that handles both. The operational awareness and emotional awareness that you needed to have as an executive team, we have to help them identify and do around M&A is so much higher than it used to be.
(00:58:11):
So no more playbooks, none of that stuff. And most teams, that's hard for them to do because they want a checklist. They want to, "Okay, I'm going to do this. We're going to migrate the platform over." The world is too disruptive and changing too fast to take for granted and you can buy a competitor, spend two years moving their customers onto your product, you're dead. So the thing that's changed, I think, is the awareness that's required for what level of integration is required and sometimes it's very little and that's okay. And that's evolved a lot I think in the last couple years.
Rick Buhrman (00:58:54):
And the deal has to make sense irrespective of that sort of lack of integration in some situations. It sort of has to stand on its own.
A.J. Rohde (00:59:04):
That is also more true than it used to be. Meaning if we didn't fully integrate it and didn't use our distribution engine to augment that and didn't have our development teams reduce cycle times by 2X, all those things, can the business hold up on its own? Is this a good capital allocation decision? If our portfolio company was a private equity firm like Beacon, would they want to buy this company or not? That level of determination is way more than it used to be also. And so because we just know what happens when you break something or you overly integrate it, especially during a time like now. And so we made that mistake too, several times where we had a great asset that was running well on its own. We bought it through a portfolio company. We overly did it, fired the wrong people, made the wrong changes and killed the company.
(00:59:52):
It doesn't happen very often, but it's happened enough where we have a lot more sensitivity to not doing that. So it's advising the teams on how to do that now. That's kind of fun actually. I really enjoyed the evolution of that mindset, but I think the teams need to hear it from us as the owners and the partners like, "No, no, this is okay. You guys don't need to fully integrate this. Let this thing flourish for a little bit and see what happens. Here's the business plan. Okay, great. Now what set of operational activities do we take and how much risk do we take to hit that plan?"
Rick Buhrman (01:00:22):
Coming back to the Thoma Bravo DNA and how you keep a bunch of really talented people together for a long time, keep them motivated, excited, feeling renewed is some level of entrepreneurialism, whatever the opposite of bureaucracy or complacency is. And maybe just as a chance to get a few more aspects of your career on the table, maybe you can just talk about how your role has evolved in the firm. I think you were involved in getting the London operations going, Discover funds, a whole set of new funds, and maybe just give us a sense for those aspects and what the firm looks like today as a bit of a CJ and run.
A.J. Rohde (01:01:08):
When I started, we had 800 million and I would say it looks no different than it used to. It's a tiny group. We can make decisions in 10 minutes together if we're together and we're prepared. There is an obsession, OCD about the business and driving it forward that there always has been. Orlando has it, I have it, Holden has it, Seth, Scott, everybody else. More time's gone by, so we've learned what not to do in some regard. That's been really helpful. And we're at another leg of our careers now where we have to redo our own heuristics around some of the underwriting patterns, some of these integration patterns on M&A that we talked about. How do we think about AI risk? That's a whole new thing for investment judgment. The way the Wolfpack operates, no different 2008, 2026. That's awesome. Yeah, I get a little bit less hair now, all that stuff, but generally it's been great.
(01:02:08):
My role, I think there was an article recently that called me Mr. Fix It Guy. I'm not sure how I got that title. I'm 10 years younger than Orlando, five and six younger than Holden and Seth. So I'm kind of like the little brother to them, to use a family analogy. And what does little brothers do who want to have their own contribution to the family? They tend to do their own thing, but within the system, they add to it, they make it better, they push everybody else. That was sort of the Discover fund. It was the baby sister fund to the main fund. I started that almost 12 years ago now. That spawned a baby sister to that. That spawned a European business. That spawned a growth fund at some point during there. So I think my contribution has been keep us middle market, keep us scrappy, keep us humble, keep us creative, keep us deep in the verticals.
(01:03:06):
All of what we do in these funds is all vertical investing, deep vertical domain expertise, and really help maintain that five year mentor-mentee connection to the rest of the firm. So we have this big brother, little brother kind of thing where everyone's five years apart from the person they work with mostly. I've been the connection point to a lot of that. I relish that role. I love it. I also like a little brother. I have very strong opinions with the rest of my partners. What I disagree with something like a little brother would, you're very vocal about that. I hope that's an appreciated contribution to the whole system. I always think about it like my job is to keep Thoma Bravo the way Thoma Bravo was in 2010. If we ever start to evolve too much from that, I'm just going to be vocal about keeping us back in that zone because those were such seminal moments in our development or 2003, even though that was before I was here.
Paul Buser (01:04:08):
All right. So A.J., take us to what does the Wolf Pack and the family feel like in late 22 when the world changes a little bit in the ChatGPT moment and then this year, the last six months, it feels like we're finally out of some of the silliness around Saspocalypse, but those two moments, what do you do as a firm to maintain what you said, you keep the firm the same, but also learn and evolve what has AI meant and how do you guys think about going forward?
A.J. Rohde (01:04:40):
Yeah, it's been interesting. I mean, every single person, I don't care what you do, has had their own emotional journey over the last few years about AI. Is it going to take my job away? Is it going to make me better? Is it going to ruin my kids' life? Is it going to make them better? What happens to my business? Everybody, and I promise you, every person has gone through this sign function of all those, optimism, pessimism, doom and gloom. So we're a collection of individuals, so it's no different. So we've all had and intersected at our own points, this is great for our business, this is scary. Well, the one guiding principle, which I think we do a really good job of, is because we have so much good data and we help manage the companies week to week, we just try to look at what's happening week to week, the pipeline, things coming in and out, the retention rate, what customers are saying.
(01:05:33):
And if you maintain that level of rigor, you can make changes or adapt quickly and you don't have a lot of structure around that. You can be entrepreneurial about how you do that. That's been great. So actually while I've gone in different points of the intersection, every time I go a little bit standard deviated too much from that, I go back to what's happening day to day, week to week. That is the most clarifying. By the way, it's not always a positive answer. Sometimes you can see an erosion or then you have to make changes, but at least that to me keeps it all this nonsense of the Silicon Valley hype machine, which has scared us and promised us the world at the same time to the enterprise reality that Alex Karp was on TV talking about two weeks ago very emotionally about this stuff is nonsense and nobody trusts it. That's absolutely not universally true, but it's absolutely true in many cases.
(01:06:31):
So we go back to that. I don't know if it brings us more comfort or less comfort, but it brings us a clear head about making those decisions. And I'm very grateful that we have a group that manages the companies with a lot of information and is creative enough to change if things are changing. So every day that's gone by after mid-January or late in February, I think we've been more optimistic, partially because the valuation environment is a little bit more normal for what we do in the public markets. We almost laughed it off, but at the same time, everything we own is marked to that. The amount of daily calls we were getting was high and going back to what the enterprises want, they want what we have to sell, but that's not going to be true forever necessarily if we don't handle it well.
(01:07:22):
But we feel really good about that right now. I hope that the macro capital flows into buying private assets or embracing software IPOs, I hope that will improve. I think some of a release of the AI capital bubble will flow back into application software. It should.
Rick Buhrman (01:07:47):
Beyond the kind of various hype machines, obviously I think any investor is going to have an interest in talking their book and that's understandable. But beyond that, these are incredibly smart people. What do you think is missed about the nature of these businesses by the folks who sort of declared all of software being dead on account of this new technology? Is it certain relational components? Is it other operational aspects? Ultimately, I think this is where the risk resides and where it doesn't, how underwriting needs to change. Is it looking for certain characteristics now in leadership that maybe you didn't five years ago? But just talk a little bit about what you think folks got wrong when anticipating such a radical shift in not just software, but obviously popularized by this apocalypse, but it was really this sense that somehow most industries are ultimately going to be kind of upended.
A.J. Rohde (01:08:52):
Disintermediated. Picking on software, first of all, it was all lumped together, which is ridiculous. Cybersecurity with developer tools, come on, and sticky applications. Then I don't think the market has ever really appreciated how much interdependency in an enterprise comes from how many people touch it, whether they know it or not, a complex software system that has been installed at that company. Anybody can rewrite an application away. I mean, we've seen it. Vibe code, people with vibe code at Salesforce and they boast about it and it's great for them. I don't think people realize the downstream processes that people who don't have a Salesforce seat license do because of the information that came out of that database and the tasks that then resulted as a result. So there's this shadow economy in the customers that is a derivative effect of the system that is put in place.
(01:10:04):
Most of the time it's a great system. Sometimes there are shit software systems out there. We'll all admit that, but that system has been put in place for years and executes with deterministic outcome because otherwise it wouldn't be there. And there are so many people that rely on that system that aren't paying for it, but rely on its decisions as a workflow step to do that. And so when people start talking about vibe coding, they really just look at the specific core process that that thing may do. For example, in Salesforce, they would think about vibe coding just a database of customer connections or customer touchpoints. Okay, sure. But you have no idea how much happens from there and therefore the notion of ripping the system out, if you talk to a good CIO, they'll be like, "I don't know what would happen if I do that." Now, so what they do is they'll try little pieces of it, and if those pieces are materially better than what was happening before, like maybe in customer support or contact center, sure, that's a better frontline tier one, tier two support because agent and identified customer support experience is better.
(01:11:19):
Okay. But I think what the market doesn't really get is the downstream effect. I think what was happening, Rick, is I think there was a trade, public markets trade that priced some of that forever, priced some of application software into perpetuity. So there was year 10 to year 20 in the model.
(01:11:44):
Take Guidewire, you put 12% growth for 20 years, you're good to go. I think what happened in SaaS apocalypse is people would start to put the growth rate of Guidewire in year eight, year nine, year 10, year 11 down to 4% and two and zero and minus two. The impact of that on valuations, and we've played with this, was 30%, and that was the SaaS apocalypse. I think the duration trade went out. I think then it was easy to pick on some other bad behaviors that software had for years, like giving out stock comp like candy. It was a huge problem. We don't do that in our companies, but the public markets do. The notion that public markets were running EBITDA margins of enterprise software at minus 2% during COVID plus three. Why is the industry for 20 years running zero margin? That's absurd. Some of it was picking on bad behaviors that deserve to be picked on but were overlooked because of other tailwinds.
(01:12:43):
Those were gone. I think the market went through this wild spin of the duration trade, the bad behaviors, but I think even today, the notion that software on a PE basis trades at a discount to the S&P median for twice the growth rate and 80% gross margins is so absurd, but I think that's the piece that's still not recognized. And that has an impact on the private business too because it just scares people that have to hold companies throughout that period of time with an uncertain exit. So that's kind of the world we've been living in.
Rick Buhrman (01:13:22):
And does anything change with your underwriting? I mean, do you need more tech savvy founders? I mean, is there aspects? Obviously there's the certain industries, certain kinds of software that would be more or less vulnerable, but maybe talk about it across the business side and the teams that you back.
A.J. Rohde (01:13:44):
We call it effortless, but we track this metric, which is gross plus consumption expansion that naturally happens in our customer base, whether it's seats or servers or payments or whatever, measure of the business model, plus a little bit of CPI inflation. That is an inviolable underwriting metric at Thoma Bravo, has, was, always will be. And that I think we then can create a separate distribution P&L. So that was always very important to our underwriting standard. We're lucky that that hasn't changed. And so when we look at what we can buy, it always has to have that. That has protected the incumbency. It will for longer, not forever, but for long. The thing that I think is jumped to the front of the line beyond the customer connection, which I talked about, is we always back existing management, but now it's like, has that team been together since the beginning of COVID and have they hit their numbers every quarter since that time?
(01:14:43):
Because if you kept a wolf pack together and executed throughout this pre-buying COVID and then the hangover from that and then GPT-3 and some of the other certainly geopolitics and tariffs, if you have executed non-renewal bookings through that period of time with consistency, that is a really rare attribute. And so when I look at what we're buying, it's got all the tenets and it's absolutely got to have that.
(01:15:18):
And that autocracy is so much more important than it used to be that we... And I think everyone's trying to find that. That's another probably inviolable thing at the moment.
Paul Buser (01:15:30):
So fascinating. And one other AI related question just coming off of... I just got back from Germany from an annual meeting of our largest holding Chapters Group, which is rolling up a bunch of software companies and other companies in Europe. And they've been AI red pilled. They have a CTO who's a particle physicist from CERN. They're doing everything. And yet when you look at it, it's become an offensive measure. And when you really talk to the platform heads and the MDs, the operating companies, there's been zero times that a customer has left or even threatened to leave because of an AI native solution. Now this is a little more SMB. It's a little smaller. I realize in much bigger enterprises that can help a little more. How do you think about that? Just almost like on the playing offense, so how do you inject more tech talent into these companies, maybe just on the AI frontier, but also have you had to play defense?
(01:16:33):
How do you keep the radar up for AI native players that obviously weren't together all through COVID, like you mentioned, or they're kind of new, but maybe it's cheaper, maybe it looks better and they're coming at one of your verticals. How do you guys react to that?
A.J. Rohde (01:16:49):
Yeah. I mean, I think if you're on the edge of the system, then I think you're more exposed because I think people will play with those AI decisions on the edge of the system. When you are the system or you anchor the system, people are not willing to even do the work yet to explore rebuilding the system because they don't know when you pull the card out what's going to happen downstream, as I mentioned before. So if you see the AI native successful applications, they tend to be on the edge of the system, like Harvey and legal, that's a great example, and done really well, but that has not really gone at the core system yet. They're trying to pick out pieces of it and eventually it probably will be successful, assuming execution wise, that team appreciates capital efficiency and all those things because a lot of these startup companies, they don't, and that was the downfall of a lot of SaaS companies in 2021.
(01:17:47):
I would say that is the difference. We don't take the AI risk on the AI native apps for granted. We say we can offer the same thing. Now, your question was a really good one is how do we do that with the talent base that we have? I think that's where the teams, the ones that are really close to their R&D and product management org, we're starting to make these changes and adaptations in 2022, or even before that actually, because people have been talking about artificial intelligence in software for 10 years. There are a lot of teams that will have either four years ago retrained some of their traditional engineers around the tools and they've stayed current or have hired AI overlays to do that. But like any business, it doesn't mean necessarily going and paying some 24 year old kid a $5 million guarantee because they know language models and coming over.
(01:18:54):
And so like anything, we've had to get smart about layering an AI talent and not reaching for a frontier that the customers don't need or want yet. It's doing it within a thoughtful bootstrap model. We don't have that perfect, nobody does, but we kind of keep that mindset going. And so the teams just kind of get scrappy and creative about how they get that talent. I'm more optimistic that there'll be labor deflation in that as that skill becomes more pervasive and more of a commodity and there'll be different tiers of that skill and we'll have the right tier of that skill will match the right salary amount, which will match exactly what the customer wants. And so that efficiency is still like this and it's going to hopefully ameliorate and come to a median over time.
Rick Buhrman (01:19:41):
This is kind of one of the things I'll take away. Again, you could argue it's sort of business 101, but customers talk and we listen, this customer obsession and ultimately these businesses that Thoma Bravo has invested in over decades, they have this embedded distribution and they have this customer relationship. And that's ultimately all we're kind of talking about, businesses going up or down. It's really customers wanting to do more with the company or less. And this idea that AI, it offers this potential disruptive threat, but also this incredible opportunity to just get a little bit closer to your customers. And if the customers are looking for identified solutions, then you're in a great place. I mean, I would imagine that most of your companies are in a great place to provide that layer, at least as a start. I think that's one of the things that is sort of in the real highs and lows over the last few years around what are the implications of AI.
(01:20:54):
I think there's just been a massive underestimation of the power of the relationship that incumbent teams have with their customers. And to the extent they've negated that or they've taken that for granted, they're probably more vulnerable.
A.J. Rohde (01:21:11):
They're rightfully on their path to obsolescence. Absolutely.
Rick Buhrman (01:21:15):
And to the extent that they're doubling down on keeping close to the customer and delivering on the things that the customer wants, it's just not how business works that you get a mass exodus to some new company just because there is this technological shift, particularly when you're in this great anchor position to provide this cutting edge set of tools, productivity, efficiency, new revenue opportunities, all of the above. And you've been kind of hitting on this from the very beginning, this orientation to the customer, the hundred conversations that you have with customers before you make a single investment, that's going to get you the answers.
A.J. Rohde (01:22:02):
The other thing too is we don't want to take away... We don't want to put them out of business. We want to help them be much better as a business. There is a... I mean, let's not underestimate the populist sentiment against the notion that these models or the ambition of those companies is to learn how these companies do business and then make those companies irrelevant to some degree. Not every time. I'm not trying to sort of -
Paul Buser (01:22:31):
A.J., don't get Rick started.
A.J. Rohde (01:22:32):
Yeah. But that's what's happening. And Alex went off on that and I appreciate that because that is absolutely the ambition. We have no ambition around that. Our only ambition is to help them be more efficient, quicker with decisions, more accurate in their compliance submittals, whatever it might be. And there's an appreciation for the relevance in that relationship, whereas I think there is becoming an increasing concern that there's some companies that want to study their customers and they want to become their customers. And that does not make people feel good.
Rick Buhrman (01:23:08):
As we wrap up just fanning out again, beyond just you as part of the Thoma Bravo team, you and your wife are extremely philanthropic. We've talked about the commitment to a lot of causes, particularly in the Midwest. And so many of us who work in this industry know how all in you have to be to do the thing with excellence in perpetuity. And yet from a distance, it seems like you have that same kind of range that maybe you were developing in sports and music and other things as a child across the arc of your adult life and how you get the most out of showing up, not just at work, but as a father, as a husband in your community still with a little time to play Padel even. My gosh. We haven't even spoken about -
A.J. Rohde (01:24:13):
The fastest growing sport in the world, apparently. Yeah. It's not magic. I need to be busy. My wife and I grew up in fairly humble backgrounds. She's from a small farm town in Indiana, Peru. We never forgot where we grew up. The preponderance of our philanthropy is helping families, namely underprivileged families, help break out of that cycle. That's incredibly important to us because we're just so grateful that we got to be in this position in life. Our kids, we try to teach them that as best we can. It's hard given where we live to do that and they don't have the connection to the Midwest that the two of us do and did. But being involved in these other things like music, like racket sports, I have a bunch of investments personally in our family office in sports. And then now with philanthropy, it actually makes you a way better investor.
(01:25:10):
You hone the skills you need in the day job. You need more empathy, right? You need more humility. You need to understand how different business models work. You need to understand what's broken about certain parts of the economy and what's working. All those things feed this giant decision tree that we all use to make our investment pattern recognition decisions. So I've actually though, and Orlando's taught this too, and Carl, do that stuff. It crowds out time for everything else. It's not like I'm working less. I'm just adding more time than I could be doing sitting around, I suppose. But it does inform the day job a lot better. And as long as it'll keep satisfying that for me, we're going to keep doing it. And so I didn't expect that to be as helpful as it has been as we've gone down this journey.
Paul Buser (01:26:00):
The energy's infectious. Next time we got to do this in person. Sounds like that might be over - St.
A.J. Rohde (01:26:06):
Pete.
Paul Buser (01:26:07):
Some Padel and St. Pete nearby here. Maybe it's just north of Peru, Indiana. Our friends at Rebuild are building Slate Auto, the newest EV in America up in Warsaw. Marin County's not a bad place to visit either, so we can come out there. This is amazing. Thanks for sharing all the history for you personally, but also Thoma Bravo. And in this moment, it's just amazing to hear how you guys are thriving and navigating these times.
A.J. Rohde (01:26:34):
Guys, I can't tell you how honored I am to be on with you guys. You guys have built an unbelievable business and access to so many people and just done it in such a normal, humble, fun, open way, in a way that totally jives with how we are. So the fact that you asked me to be on this, it's been a real joy of mine. So I say thank you and hopefully the start of a friendship, but thanks again for doing what you do. Putting a human face to otherwise an industry that sort of labels people as certain things, I think is really important for anyone at any stage of their life just to see that everybody's a normal person, trying to make normal decisions and sometimes you just keep it simple. I appreciate a lot what you guys bring to the world, so thank you.
Rick Buhrman (01:27:21):
Thanks A.J. It's been an honor and a privilege.
Orlando Bravo (01:27:27):
Listen to Thoma Bravo's Behind the Deal on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.